Chefs Say Not to Cook Mushrooms This Way—but It’s Faster, Easier, and Just as Delicious

The perfect sautéed mushrooms are golden and glossy, tender but never limp, with a deep, meaty richness. Too often, though, they slump into a pale, rubbery heap, bleeding out liquid until the pan looks watery—nothing like the bronzed, bistro-style mushrooms you were dreaming of.

The problem isn't the mushrooms—it's the standard approach to cooking them. Mushrooms are 85 to 95% water, and most recipes tell you to toss whole or sliced mushrooms straight into a hot pan with a bit of butter and oil. This results in their moisture leaking out bit by bit, steaming the mushrooms so they're imp and soggy, never having a chance to develop that golden, bistro-style crust.The good news is there’s a smarter, easier way to get them golden: Steam first, then sear.

The 5 Key Steps for Golden, Savory Mushrooms

Steaming before searing might sound counterintuitive—after all, I just spent two paragraphs pointing out how mushrooms steaming in the pan is the problem. But as our senior culinary editor, Leah, demonstrates in her wonderful sautéed mushroom recipe: The issue isn't the steaming itself. You actually want the mushrooms to steam—just on your terms. By covering the skillet for the first few minutes, you force that moisture out quickly. Once that happens, the mushrooms are free to start sizzling away in the hot, uncovered pan and finally turn golden brown. Here's the step-by-step breakdown for how to do it:

1. Prep the mushrooms. Start by giving your mushrooms the right cut. Tiny button or cremini mushrooms (about 1/2 inch wide) can stay whole—the orbs will look extra cute once browned. Medium ones (about 1 to 1 1/2 inches in diameter) should be halved, and the larger ones (about 1 1/2 to 3 inches in diameter) can be quartered so they cook evenly. Shiitakes come with fibrous stems that don't cook down well—trim them off, then quarter the larger caps (those that are about 1 1/2 to 3 inches in diameter) and halve the small ones (which are about 1 to 1 1/2 inches in diameter). Oyster and stemmed maitake mushrooms are happiest when you just tear them into bite-size clusters of about 1 inch each—no knife required.
2. Start with steam. Melt a couple of tablespoons of butter (or olive oil, or another oil if you prefer) in a wide skillet—preferably cast iron, carbon steel, or stainless steel—over medium heat. Slip in some minced shallots, if you'd like, and let them sizzle just long enough to soften. Then add your mushrooms with a good pinch of salt to draw out their moisture. Cover, raise the heat to medium-high, and let them go. In about 8 to 10 minutes, depending on your batch size, they'll release a gush of liquid and shrink dramatically, their flavor concentrating and becoming more woodsy as they soften.
3. Uncover and sear. Now for the fun part: Lift the lid and let the liquid bubble away. With the water evaporated, the mushrooms finally meet the hot pan directly. Stir every so often, and watch as they darken to a deep bronze, their edges turning crisp while the kitchen fills with a nutty, roasted aroma.
4. Finish with flair. Right before you pull them off the heat, stir in some aromatics and herbs, if you'd like—minced garlic and fresh thyme leaves are a great combo—and give themabout 30 seconds to release their fragrance. Then splash in some vinegar to brighten the savory flavors (I like sherry vinegar for its complexity, but use whatever you like) along with a bit of water. As the water and vinegar bubble, scrape up the browned bits; those toasty fragments mix into the juices and stick to the mushrooms, amplifying their depth. I like to finish the mushrooms with a cold knob of butter, mixing it in off the heat so it melts into a silky, rich gloss.

The Best Ways to Put Your Sautéed Mushrooms to Work

With a skillet full of properly browned mushrooms, the possibilities are endless. Spoon them over buttery scrambled eggs on sourdough for brunch, pile them onto a cheesy flatbread, or let them share a plate with a perfectly seared steak. They're just as happy tossed with pasta, folded into a risotto, or scattered over a salad for an earthy, savory hit. However you use them, this steam-then-sear trick guarantees mushrooms that are tender, golden, and worthy of center stage.